How Do These Winter Boots Stack Up?

In this edition, our footwear experts thought it would be helpful, and interesting, to delve into a couple trending winter boot brands! Koolaburra by Ugg and BEARPAW are two of the most popular brands of cozy footwear, but which one is right for you? Here we’ll compare the two, in the hopes that it will help you make an informed decision the next time you’re shopping for the best winter boots or cozy footwear. We’ll investigate key details such as price, comfort, durability, and style, which will uncover pros and cons of each.


Koolaburra by UGG boots have a trendy, more fashionable look, and savvy shoppers favor the wide range of color options and detailing designs. Typically made of suede with sheepskin lining and faux fur, they are available in colors ranging from vibrant to classic black, brown, gray, and chestnut. Koolaburra has a wide style spectrum that includes ankle boots, winter booties, knee-high boots, and shearling-lined slippers.

BEARPAW boots also come in different styles, although there are fewer options and the collection has a more casual footwear look than that of Koolaburra. They are made of suede or nylon with a sheepskin or wool blend lining, but BEARPAW has fewer options when it comes to detailing and color selection, which for the most part is limited to black, brown, and gray. BEARPAW boots also come in different styles, including ankle boots, knee-high boots, footbed sandals, and shearling-lined slippers.


Koolaburra by UGG boots as well as BEARPAW boots are made with sheepskin, which is a natural insulator that helps keep your feet warm and dry. But because Koolaburra boots have a thicker sheepskin lining, extra fleece, and a more contoured footbed for better arch support, they tend to be more comfortable than BEARPAW boots.


While Koolaburra and BEARPAW are built alike, Koolaburra boots are superior in terms of durability. BEARPAW boots are made with quality materials, but Koolaburra boots have a sturdier construction that uses higher quality, water-resistant materials. Additionally, Koolaburra boots feature a reinforced toe and heel.


Because they are constructed using higher quality materials, Koolaburra by UGG boots tend to be more expensive than BEARPAW boots. Pricing depends on where you buy, but at Shoe Carnival Koolaburra boots range from $60-$110, whereas BEARPAW boots‘ maximum price is around $75, and can be as low as $50 on certain styles.

Koolaburra vs BEARPAW in a Nutshell

Koolaburra by UggBEARPAW
PriceMore expensive
(Average price: $60-$110)
Less expensive
(Average price: $50-$75)
ComfortMore comfortableLess comfortable (but still cozy!)
DurabilityMore durable constructionQuality construction, but less durable
Water ResistanceMore resistant to waterLess resistant to water
Customer FeedbackFoam sole makes them lightweight, but the heel wears quickly. The sheepskin is warmer and longer lasting. Extra layer of fleece makes them more comfortable.Sturdy rubber sole is durable, but makes them heavier. The sheepskin upper does not last as long, and they are less comfortable.

Koolaburra vs BEARPAW, the Results Are In!

When examined in contrast to one another, Koolaburra by Ugg prevails over BEARPAW in regards to style, comfort, and durability, while the latter has a more affordable price point. We’ve observed differences as well as similarities, but both are recognized as top brands for stylish and affordable winter boots and cozy footwear.

When it comes to choosing for yourself, personal preferences and individual needs should not be neglected. If you want a more fashionable boot that’s both comfortable and durable, Koolaburra by UGG is the better choice. But if you’re on a tight budget or don’t mind sacrificing style for affordability, you’ll likely favor BEARPAW boots. Winter weather conditions are also important to consider. Dry or warmer winter climates don’t necessarily need water-resistant winter boots, but in snowy, icy, and rainy regions it will be worth the higher cost of durable, water-resistant boots. Ultimately, the best way to decide which brand of winter boots or cozy boots is right for you is to try on a few different pairs and see which ones you like best!

Here are some additional things to consider when choosing between Koolaburra by UGG and BEARPAW boots:

  • Fit: Koolaburra boots tend to run true to size, whereas BEARPAW boots are known to run on the smaller side.
  • Width: Both brands offer wide-width boot options.
  • Features: Koolaburra boots often have additional features, such as a waterproof membrane or a removable insole. BEARPAW styles typically do not have these features.

For a limited time get up to 25% off select Koolaburra by Ugg boots at Shoe Carnival! Sale ends January 11, 2024.